And that oddness is what both had in common. To answer yesterday conundrum - what made the stories nearly identical is that both were re-published twice, each time with the names, even story details, changed.
Both of these stories originally ran in Red Seal Comics, just a few issues apart in 1946. Both were republished two years later in 1948, and then again in 1950 & '52, diverging a bit at the end.
George Tuska's Gay Desperado, not to be confused with Fred Guardineer's Gay Desperado, ran from mid-1945 to mid-'47 and has had stories reprinted as recently as 2016. The Gay Desperado name seems to have lost its cachet over the years, and he was renamed The Bold Buckaroo and The Lone Vigilante in the republished versions. But that wasn't enough, it seems. Jim Collins became Tim Rollins became Tom Cullen. Here are all three versions of this story, in publication order -
In a demonstration of customer contempt that would fit right in with today's corporations, that last version of the tale above was published only 8 issues after the previous version - in the same damn title.
Meanwhile, the second version below is from Authentic Police Cases, running a retread of a Lady Satan story. Authentic enough for the History Channel.
Another link between these two stories - although this Lady Satan tale is drawn by Ralph Mayo, the original artist on the series was none other than George Tuska. Mayo drew three Lady Satan stories that i know of, putting him even with Tuska.
You'll note more dramatic changes to the story on this next one, especially since she's not a superhero in the later versions -
Lady Satan was also reprinted in 2016, along with The Gay Desperado. Both were in Gwandanaland Comics, if you want to go hunting. Lady Satan saw more action with them.
page art by George Tuska and Ralph Mayo for Red Seal Comics #s 15 & 18, The Texan #s 1 & 9, Authentic Police Cases # 5, and Strange Terrors #1 (1946, 1948, 1950, 1952)
